UTSA researcher explores transnational identity through Olympic controversy

Of the 15 players selected by the Mexican Softball Federation to represent Mexico, 14 were born and raised in the United States. Scholars identify them as transnationals: individuals with strong, simultaneous connections to multiple countries and cultures.

Frequently, transnationals maintain ties to more than one country through residencies, businesses and familial connections, resulting in fluid identities and a sense of belonging across borders. However, this identity often leads to marginalization and exclusion by others.

"Transnationalism and transnational identities should be seen in a different way," said Christiansen, a UTSA associate professor of bicultural-bilingual studies. "We need to move away from a binary of you belong to a single territory, and therefore you have or represent a single symbol, color, or language, to you belong to a group of people that have similar specific cultural practices."

Christiansen expands on her research in transnationalism and the use of language in, "'Pochas sin identidad': Raciolinguistic ideologies in the construction of mexicandad in online spaces," an article exploring how individuals use language to negotiate their identities, cultures, and membership.

Christiansen conducted a discourse analysis on the comments from the boxers' tweets and the apologies the softball players issued. She analyzed a total of 9,670 comments, which emphasized different aspects of Mexican identity.

Utilizing a social network for this research was significant. Transnational populations use online spaces to reaffirm their identities, connect with similar individuals, and build communities. The ease and accessibility of these platforms allows individuals to navigate areas where they have multiple connections.

Christiansen found that it is common for people to define identities and vie for cultural membership based on their own criteria of language fluency (ability to speak Spanish), skin and/or hair color and other observable characteristics.

Looking at the exchanges on X, Christiansen found comments by many followers who attacked the softball players' language skills and used misogynistic language to discuss the players' bodies, sexuality and intellect.

Further analysis of the accusations, apologies, and replies revealed that the softball players struggled with the expectations of representing two countries that have strict and singular ideas of Mexican and American identity. These perspectives portray the players as not Mexican enough or American enough.

Asian American Olympians confronted comparable accusations during the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics, when Chinese nationals attacked the U.S.-born Olympians when they lost. The attacks that the Asian American Olympians faced about language and identity led to exclusion similar to what the Mexican-American softball players experienced.

Christiansen plans to further investigate how individuals negotiate identities through language, focusing on how English-dominant Mexican Americans navigate their identities within Mexico or when interacting with Spanish-dominant Mexicans.

"A lot of research unfortunately is biased or one-sided," stated Christiansen, whose article is in the International Multilingual Research Journal. "Researchers often present the side of the U.S. only, and if you only look at that side, it is very easy to judge the other country."

She continued, "Expecting individuals to conform to a rigid 'one language, one country, one culture' ideology hinders growth and acceptance of diversity. The Olympics exemplify multiculturalism and multilingualism, which are the global norm. Embracing this reality can benefit U.S. and Mexican societies by acknowledging the multifaceted ways people identify and express themselves. This includes the ability to love and belong to multiple languages, cultures and belief systems simultaneously."

Public link

Please use the above public link if you want to share this noodl on another website.