State Comptroller DiNapoli Releases Municipal & School Audits

August 23, 2024

New York State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli today announced the following local government and school audits were issued.

Northeastern Clinton Central School District - Transportation State Aid (Clinton County)

District officials did not accurately apply for all applicable transportation aid. As a result, the district was at risk of losing aid totaling $391,494. However, once auditors informed officials of this risk, the school business manager promptly filed accurate aid applications with the State Education Department, and the aid was subsequently approved. Had officials established procedures to ensure transportation aid applications were accurately filed, the district's aid may not have been delayed.

Northeastern Clinton Central School District - Foster Care Tuition Billing (Clinton County)

District officials did not properly bill tuition for nonresident foster care students enrolled at the district. As a result, as of June 30, 2023, officials had not billed $95,210 of the $129,538 in tuition to which it was entitled for the 2020-21 through 2022-23 school years and made tuition calculation errors totaling $3,036 in the amounts billed.

Campbell-Savona Central School District - Student State Aid (Steuben County)

District officials did not properly claim a total of $65,953 in potential state aid for special education and homeless students, including $29,939 of potential aid the district will not receive because officials did not file claims within the filing timeframes. Specifically, $57,176 in estimated state aid was not properly claimed by the district for some special education students and $8,777 in potential state aid was not properly claimed for some students classified as homeless.

Town of Summit - Town Clerk (Schoharie County)

Although fees were properly recorded, the town clerk did not always deposit or remit fees in a timely manner. Specifically, the clerk did not deposit 98% of the fees collected in accordance with state law which requires the clerk to deposit fees within three business days after total collections exceed $250. The clerk also did not perform monthly bank reconciliations or accountability analyses during the audit period.

Erie 2-Chautauqua-Cattaraugus Board of Cooperative Educational Services (BOCES) - Building Access Badge Accounts

BOCES officials did not properly manage and monitor badge accounts used to access BOCES buildings. Badges that remain active without a purpose can be lost, stolen or misused, potentially resulting in unauthorized building access. BOCES officials did not deactivate 48 badges that were no longer needed out of the 87 active non-employee individual badge accounts. They also created 25 duplicate accounts in the building access system and physical badges for current BOCES employees who already had badges. In addition, they did not deactivate and could not physically locate the badges for 15 of 25 shared accounts selected for testing. Lastly, an additional 48 shared accounts were discovered and deactivated because the badges were lost.

Town of Harpersfield - Claims Auditing (Delaware County)

The board did not properly audit claims to determine whether the claims represented actual and necessary expenditures and whether proposed payments were for valid purposes. Of the 428 claims totaling $478,628 that were paid during the audit period, auditors reviewed 124 claims totaling $400,604 and determined that the board did not properly audit individual claim packets and supporting documentation. Rather, the board reviewed only an abstract of unaudited claims each month and approved the abstracts for payment. Auditors found 30 claims totaling $69,281 were improperly paid before board approval and 22 claims were paid that included sales tax totaling $460.

Town of Otselic - Audit Follow Up (Chenango County)

Town officials have made almost no progress on implementing corrective action proposed in the original audit. Of the 11 audit recommendations, one was fully implemented, one recommendation was partially implemented, and nine recommendations were not implemented, including the recommendation that the board should require the supervisor to provide accurate monthly financial reports.