Iowa’s “Lean-in” approach to successful permitting reform

The State of Iowa has made significant strides in improving its environmental permitting processes, thanks to innovative reforms spearheaded by the state's Department of Natural Resources (DNR). Our recent report, Corn Whiskey Clarity: Iowa's Spirited Approach to Permitting Reform, provides a detailed analysis of these reforms, focusing on how the state has implemented business process improvement methodologies like Lean and Kaizen to streamline operations. The report underscores the effectiveness of these strategies in reducing permit processing times, increasing transparency, and enhancing customer service.

The genesis of reform

The push for reform began in 2003 when business leaders approached the Iowa DNR to address the lengthy and cumbersome pollution permitting process, particularly for Air Quality New Source Construction Permits. This marked the beginning of the state's journey toward more efficient government services. Iowa's DNR adopted a private-sector concept called "Hot Teams," which focuses on improving key processes that act as barriers to business development.

This initiative gave rise to the state's first "Kaizen event" in June 2003, an intensive improvement process aimed at identifying inefficiencies and streamlining workflows. Over time, Iowa's DNR became a pioneer in state-level process improvement, holding more than 400 events across its executive branch.

The role of Lean and Kaizen

Central to Iowa's success was the application of Lean methodologies, which originated in the manufacturing sector but were adapted for government use. Lean emphasizes maximizing value while minimizing waste, and Kaizen events focus on rapid, incremental improvements. The DNR utilized these methodologies to reduce waste, increase efficiency, and make government services "easier, faster, better, and less costly."

For instance, a 2008 review highlighted how Lean processes helped Iowa's DNR reduce complex air quality permit processing times from 214 days to 180 days. Even more dramatically, some New Source Review permits, which previously took 62 days to process, were cut down to just six days. In addition to faster processing times, the DNR eliminated 16 steps from the air quality permitting process and reduced the number of internal handoffs from 18 to 4, demonstrating the potential for process simplification.

Beyond permitting: Transparency and technology

One essential feature of Iowa's reforms has been the integration of new technology. The Iowa Environmental Services Division Metrics dashboard offers real-time data on permit applications across various divisions, including air, land, and water quality. This platform allows applicants and the public to track the status of permit applications, and it has become a tool for monitoring the agency's performance.

Moreover, the e-AirPermit system, which was fully launched in 2019 after years of development, has reduced paperwork and expedited the permit application process for businesses. The system allows companies to submit and track applications online, providing a more efficient and user-friendly experience.

Continuous improvement

Today, Iowa's DNR continues to conduct regular reviews and updates to its processes based on stakeholder feedback and performance data. One of the primary drivers of success has been the state's investment in ongoing staff training, ensuring that employees are equipped to leverage Lean tools and new technologies to further improve service delivery.

In addition, Iowa's experience has set a model for other states. The Environmental Protection Agency has recognized the state's achievements, and the DNR has participated in national workgroups to share its approach with others. The data-driven success of these reforms, alongside a commitment to continuous improvement, suggests that Iowa's innovative approach will continue to benefit both businesses and environmental protection efforts well into the future.

• By: Clyde Wayne Crews
• 09/25/2024

Presidential executive orders and directives have long played a pivotal role in shaping federal policies and regulations. As President Obama famously remarked in 2014, "I've…

Regulatory Reform

• By: Clyde Wayne Crews
• 09/23/2024

It's been repeated a million times that in our constitutional republic, lawmaking power belongs to Congress. But over the years, this authority has increasingly shifted…

Regulatory Reform

• By: Daren Bakst
• 09/04/2024

Taxation without representation is the antithesis of freedom and runs counter to the basic principles guiding our nation. So why is regulation without representation not…

Deregulation