Dark Matter Solves Butterfly Evolutionary Mystery

A team of international researchers led by scientists from George Washington University's Department of Biology has uncovered a surprising genetic mechanism that influences the vibrant and complex patterns on butterfly wings.

In a study published in the "Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences," the team, led by Luca Livraghi, a biology postdoctoral scientist at GW's Columbian College of Arts and Sciences and the University of Cambridge, discovered that an RNA molecule, rather than a protein as previously thought, plays a pivotal role in determining the distribution of black pigment on butterfly wings.

Precisely how butterflies are able to generate the vibrant patterns and colors on their wings has fascinated biologists for centuries. The genetic code contained within the cells of developing butterfly wings dictates the specific arrangement of the color on the wing's scales-the microscopic tiles that form wing patterns-similar to the arrangement of colored pixels to form a digital image.

Cracking this code is fundamental to understanding how our own genes build our anatomy. In the lab, researchers can manipulate that code in butterflies with gene-editing tools and observe the effect on visible traits, such as coloration on a wing.

Scientists have long known that protein-coding genes are crucial to these processes. These types of genes create proteins that can dictate when and where a specific scale should generate a particular pigment. When it comes to black pigments, researchers thought this process would be no different, and initially implicated a protein-coding gene.

The new research, however, paints a different picture.

A longwing butterfly with one wing (right) altered by CRISPR gene editing, resulting in a dramatic change to its normal color pattern.

The team discovered that a gene that produces an RNA molecule-not a protein-controls where dark pigments are made during butterfly metamorphosis. Using the genome-editing technique CRISPR, the researchers demonstrated that removing the gene that produces the RNA molecule causes butterflies to completely lose their black pigmented scales, showing a clear link between RNA activity and dark pigment development.

"What we found was astonishing," said Livraghi, a lead author of the study. "This RNA molecule directly influences where the black pigment appears on the wings, shaping the butterfly's color patterns in a way we hadn't anticipated."

An evolutionary paintbrush

The researchers further explored how the RNA molecule functions during wing development. By examining its activity, they observed a perfect correlation between where the RNA is expressed and where black scales form.

"We were amazed that this gene is turned on where the black scales will eventually develop on the wing, with exquisite precision," said Arnaud Martin, associate professor of biology at GW and an author on the study. "It is truly an evolutionary paintbrush in this sense, and a creative one, judging by its effects in several species."

The researchers examined the newly discovered RNA in several other butterflies whose evolutionary history diverged around 80 million years ago. They found that in each of these species, the RNA had evolved to control new placements in the patterns of dark pigments.

A longwing butterfly resting on a Lantana flower. After CRISPR gene editing removed an RNA molecule, its wing patterns experienced a loss of melanic scales.

"The consistent result obtained from CRISPR mutants in several species really demonstrate that this RNA gene is not a recent invention, but a key ancestral mechanism to control wing pattern diversity," said Riccardo Papa, professor of biology at the University of Puerto Rico-Río Piedras.

"We and others have now looked at this genetic trait in many different butterfly species, and remarkably we are finding that this same RNA is used again and again, from longwing butterflies to monarchs and painted lady butterflies," said Joe Hanly, a postdoctoral scientist and visiting fellow at GW. "It's clearly a crucial gene for the evolution of wing patterns. I wonder what other, similar phenomena biologists might have been missing because they weren't paying attention to the dark matter of the genome."

The findings not only challenge long-standing assumptions about genetic regulation but also open new avenues for studying how visible traits evolve in animals.

The study, titled "A long noncoding RNA at the cortex locus controls adaptive coloration in butterflies," was supported by the National Science Foundation and the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council.