at these days because Ben talks to a broad
range of guests. You're sure to find a show that covers a type of
marketing technology that could
really make a d
ifference within your business,
such as digital assistance, email marketing, or even
dynamic live. As a result, you might find yourself doing a little binge of this show the same way I did
listen to MarTech wh
erever you get your podcasts.
All right, before we get into this episode, I want to just give you a quick heads up, but we are gonna
be covering some tough topi
cs,
including maternal mortality. So if this is gonna put you into a weird
or not so go
od place, definitely skip to the second half of this episode or skip it all together. I wanna
make sure that you keep your mind right.
When I was pregnant with Luna, Jonathan and I were living in Argentina, so basically for my entire
pregnancy and for her
delivery,
all of that happened in Bueno Aires.
Now, for me, pregnancy was a blissful time, but still even with that throughout pregnancy, there were
a number of emotions that I had to manage, and because of that, there were certain data points and
source
s that I often had to make sure that I limited my intake of.
One of those thing
s was maternal mortality rates,
and you might think of, Hey, Sonia, why are you
thinking about maternal mortality while you're pregnant? But unfortunately, as a black woman, th
ose
pretty horrific data points were something that I was very much aware of.
According to the CDC in the US in 2020, for women overall, there were 23.8 maternal deaths for
every
a hundred thousand live births.
But when you zero in on this number by demog
raphic, there's
a clear outlier in the data. When you look at the maternal mortality rate for black women, it's nearly
double that of the national average at 55.3 deaths for every 100,000 live births.
Now, the US already has a very high maternal mortality
rate, especially whenever you start
comparing it to other co
untries that have high incomes.
One data report showed that while the US
sits at 23.8 deaths per 100,000 live births, the 12 other countries that they compared them to,
including the UK, Canada,
France, South Korea, Netherlands, and Japan ranged from 1.2 to 13.6.
As mentioned, the numbers in the US are quite high in general, but the numbers are just plain
alarming whenever you look at it For black women in the US.
IM_Ep 45_Factors That Influence Your Customers' Success That You Need To Be Aware Of.pdf
2
For my own personal situation
, I was extremely thankful to be giving birth to Luna in Argentina. My
entire care experience from start to finish was an absolute dream, even though we had to make a
few adjustments that last month because the pandemic hit.
But this isn't a case where I
wanna say, Hey, I was okay, so let me not pay attention to a glaring
issue th
at impacts so many other lives.
That's how problems persist.
I bring this topic up on this show today because as marketers and business leaders, the experiences
of people who are part of marginalized communities are often very different from the experiences of
the masses.
And a lot of those instances, the discrepan
cies in the experience aren't really talked about. But if we
looked at the data, we'll see a very different and very clear story.
In the US for instance, we definitely know that there are differences in the quality of care and
outc
omes that exist based upo
n race.
A
nd there's plenty of data to support that one 2016 study. And here's the actual title of it, racial bias
and pain assessment and treatment recommendations and false Beliefs about biological differences
between blacks and whites. Now, this study w
as published in Psychological and cognitive sciences.
The research showed that half of medical students believed that there were biological differences
between black people and white people, and those beliefs impacted how they were actually treating
their
patients.
Here's the abstract of the study. Now it's a bit
medical, so stick with me here:
It's important. Black Americans are systematically undertreated for pain relative to white Americans.
We examine whether this racial bias is related to false
beliefs about biological differences between
blacks and whites. (For example, black people's skin is thicker than white people's skin.) Study one
documented these beliefs among white laypersons and revealed that participants who more strongly
endorse false
beliefs about biological differences reported lower pain ratings for a black (
v
s white
)
target. Study two extended these findings to the medical context and found that half of a sample of
white medical students in residence endorsed these beliefs. Moreove
r, participants who endorsed
the
se beliefs rated the black (v
s white
)
patients pain as lower and made less accurate treatment
recommendations. Participants who did not endorse these beliefs rated the black (vs white
)
patient's
pain as higher, but showed no
bias in treatment. These findings suggest that individuals with at least
some medical training hold and may use false beliefs about biological differences between blacks
and whites to inform medical judgements which may contribute to racial disparities in
pain
assessment and treatment.
To be clear, there should be no race based disparities in treatments, outcomes, or experience within
healthcare. Here's what one nurse I talked to on the topic h
ad to say.
IM_Ep 45_Factors That Influence Your Customers' Success That You Need To Be Aware Of.pdf
3
Candis
:
I'm just trying to think of a disease where the race matters. For the majority of the things,
majority of the disease processes or whatever, when a patient comes in their race has nothing to do
with what's happening.
If you twisted your ankle, what does y
ou being black have to do with your ankle being broken?
Nothing. But as far as medicine and healthcare and how we treat people, it should not be the, it
should not be at the forefront at all.
Now, as I mentioned, race should not impact outc
omes or treatment in healthcare, but the data
shows that it actually does.
This discrepancy in outcomes isn't just limited to the realm of healthcare.
In 2021 Beauty Retailer, Sephora published the results of a large scale research study that they had
com
missioned entitled The Racial Bias and Retail Study. I'll link it up in the show notes in case
you're interested in digging into the full 17 page report. It's super well done, and it's quite fascinating.
In this study, which was industry
-
wide from a retail
standpoint, they found that three and five retail
shoppers have experienced discriminatory treatment. Two and five have personally experienced
unfair treatment on the basis of their race or skin color. And three and five retail employees have
actually wit
nessed bias at their place of work.
Now, this bias doesn't just impact consumers, it exten
ds to retail employees as well.
The studies
show that one in three retail employees have contemplated quitting when they experience racial
bias and unfair treatment.
Now, in response to the report, John Andre Rugo, CEO and president of Sephora America's
reiterated that diversity, equity, and inclusion are core parts of their mission and values. He also
acknowledged that racial bias was at the core of many negative cu
stomer experiences by diverse
shoppers.
I found this quote
from him particularly important:
"B
ut the reality is that the retail experience is not always inclusive to all. The very real issue of
underlying racial bias remains a barrier to ensuring that a
ll of our clients enjoy the sense of belonging
we strive to foster.
"
So we know there's race
-
based disparities in outcomes in healthcare, and we also know that there
are race
-
based disparities and experie
nces in the retail environment,
but there are also
race
-
based
and gender
-
based disparities in outcomes and venture capital.
A 2022 report by nonprofit firm diversity VC showed that only 1.87% of 31 billion worth of venture
capital funds had been allocated to startups with diverse leaders.
Sarah Miller,
chief operating officer at Diversity VC talked about the findin
gs of the report and noted
this:
IM_Ep 45_Factors That Influence Your Customers' Success That You Need To Be Aware Of.pdf
4
"
What we found was that VC back startups wer
e still disproportionately men,
(
89.3%
)
white,
(
71.6%
)
based in Silicon Valley,
(
35.3%
)
, and Ivy League educated
(
13.7%
)
. She also noted that the data
had Harley changed in two years.
"
This comparison to two years prior is a nod to everything that happened in summer 2020 after the
murder of George Floyd, when a number of companies across all industries, including th
ose in the
venture capital pledge, that they would do better with regards to diversity,
equity, and inclusion,
race
-
based and gender based disparities are rampant, and these are in areas where we have actual
data, but what about the disparities that exist
in other industries that still impact a lot of people, even
though we might not have the data to show it? This happens at the consumer level, it happens at
the employee level, and it happens even at the provider level.
Whenever we think about the people wh
o are offering the products, services, and experiences, the
entrepreneurs, the business leaders.
A while back I chatted with Megan Williams who heads the Black freelance online community. She
told me that one of the reasons why she started Black Freelance
was to get answers to common
questions that she was hearing and having herself that weren't found in more mainstream spaces.
Megan:
When I first started freelancing, you know, you're out there, you're learning about things,
and I started running into jus
t some general questions. Like, one of the things that people, you'll
hear a lot of just mainstream freelancers advise people is to post your picture online.
So I started doing that and I noticed that in a couple and maybe ac
tually two specific situations
,
you
know, we were having really good back and forth, people seemed excited, and I saw them check
my LinkedIn and all of a sudden they disappeared and my LinkedIn didn't say anything different than
my website. So you know, that question is in my head, it'
s like, is this because I'm black? Right?
And it
might not have been, you know,
I didn't know.
But what it made me realize is that I had no one to go to, to ask. That kind of question made me
realize not only that there was a need for a site for black fre
elancers, but that people's actually made
me realize that. But then it's more as I started to build the site and started listening to more people's
Lance stories
,
and that's any freelancer, white, black, Asian, Hispanic, whatever, I started to notice
how
their businesses were shaped by their networks and the cultura
l experiences they were having.
Sonia:
Okay
Megan:
And if we realize that people's freelancers experience are not, you know, culturally neutral,
everyone is having, everyone's experience is sha
ped by something bigger than themselves.
Sonia:
Okay
Megan:
So that you know,
we needed to start paying attention or like I wanted to start paying
attention to, you know how black freelancers careers are shaped by their cultural experiences.
IM_Ep 45_Factors That Influence Your Customers' Success That You Need To Be Aware Of.pdf
5
And in the world of entrepreneurship, there are plenty of unconsciou
s biases that many B
lack
people, as well as other people from marginalized and underrepresented communities have to deal
with on a regular basis
that their peers, counterparts,
who
are part of the dominant group do not
have to experience popular b
usiness c
oach
Jereshia
Hawk went into a lot of detail about this and
her personal experiences with it in a r
eal, she published on Instagram
-
I'll link to it in the show notes
so you can se
e it for yourself.
Alright, we'll get to why so many experiences are different for people
from marginalized communities
right after this short break.
T
he other day I watched a frustrating customer experience unfold. Jonathan, my husband, was
calling
the cellphone company. He pressed the button to talk to someone in Spanish, and the phone
system then switched over to Spanish, which it should have only to have a live person come on the
line in English whenever you can. It is good practice to avoid fric
tion in the customer journey.
It really helps in delivering experiences that make more of your customers, including those who are
often underrepresented and underserved, feel like they belong. Sometimes doing that is easier said
than done, but with HubSpot
, it actually is easy. That's why more companies are choosing HubSpot
CRM, a platform that brings your marketing, sales, and service teams together all in one place.
It seamlessly connects your teams. Sales, marketing, customer service and ops have a compl
ete
view of the customer journey with real
-
time data at their fingertips. Your teams won't trip over each
other and you'll be equipped to deliver better customer experiences, which leads to more customers.
Ditch the friction and your customer experience. L
earn how HubSpot CRM can help your business
grow
[email protected]
.
All right, let's talk about why so many experiences across industries are different for people from
marginalized communities. I've already allud
ed to several of them, but let's go ahead and call them
out specifically.
First up is privilege. We all have some degree of privilege, and I'm definitely not saying that privilege
is a bad thing. How
ever, we do need to get better.
Acknowledging that privi
lege does exist and
noting the impact that privilege has on people's success, the time it takes to get there, and the
resources that are required.
Using the venture capital example, a man who went to an Ivy League college has baked in privileges
that incr
ease his likelihood of achieving funding for his startup than a woman or even a woman of
color who also went to an Ivy League university.
We gotta start acknowledging privilege and the role it plays in the outcomes that the people you
serve achieve.
Another factor that's at play is bias, both conscious and unconscious. Now, using healthcare as an
example, if medical professionals believe that black patients have a higher tolerance for pain, then
the data shows that they are going to undertreat them fo
r pain, which of course influences negatively
their outcome.
IM_Ep 45_Factors That Influence Your Customers' Success That You Need To Be Aware Of.pdf
6
I included conscious bias here because even though I want to believe in the good of everyone and
that nobody would intentionally do anything to harm another person, I also don't want to be so na
ive
as to think that people aren't aware of the biases that they have. And then sometimes those same
people will lean into acting in accordance with those beliefs.
Another reason why disparitie
s exist in both the treatments,
experiences and success rates
of
people from underrepresented and underserved communities in comparison to dominant groups is
because of negative stereotypes.
Now, let's say there's a negative stereotype out there that black people are lazy, and I'm not just
pulling this one out of th
e air. This one actually exists. I'm gonna drop a link to an academic paper
that discusses this
stereotype where it originated,
how it has been perpetuated for generations in
the show notes.
So if you held the belief or the negative stereotype that black
people were lazy and then you found
out that someone that you were considering hiring as black, that belief can cause you to either
decide not to work with them, perhaps to try to pay them lower than what you were
intending to pay
someone else,
or it can e
ven cause you to have them jump through additional hoops to be able to
get the job that other people don't have to go through.
And one additional reason I want to know for why the experiences and the outcomes for people who
are part of marginalized commun
ity are often different is because of unawareness.
When you are unaware of the plight and the experiences and the differences in the outcomes that
people from underrepresented and unde
rserved communities experience,
then it doesn't even
register in your radar of what types of things from an equity standpoint you could be or should be
doing to level the playing field so that those outcomes can be more consistent for all the people that
you serve.
Now, I walked through
a number of different examples in various industries of where disparities
exist, and we really just cannot assume that these disparities don't exist within our own industries or
even our own brands that we work on.
That's why it is essential that you beco
me aware of the disparities that exist for people for
underrepresented and underserved communities, particularly within your industry and your brand.
Why? Because whenever you know that certain groups receive different outcomes, then you can
work to put p
roducts, services, experiences, processes, systems in place that help to level a playing
field so that everyone can achieve the same types of outcomes that directly address those problems
for the brand that you work on.
I worked with one client a while bac
k who was looking at the data that was showing that the black
community in particular had higher incidents of complications associated with Covid and they were
getting vaccinated at lower rates than other communities. So they worked to implement
programmin
g specifically focus on the black community that helped them improve their covid related
outcomes and stay healthy.
In addition, as you're working to improve the outcomes and level of playing field of what's happening
in your own brand and business,
you c
an also expand your efforts to your industry at large.
IM_Ep 45_Factors That Influence Your Customers' Success That You Need To Be Aware Of.pdf