11th High-Level Dialogue on Democracy, Governance and Human Rights

An upsurge of Unconstitutional Changes of Government (UCG) has been a phenomenon on our continent recently with a number of African Union (AU) Member States (MS) grappling with a comeback of coups - military, silent coups. UCG are a culmination of several factors entrenched in the lack of strong and effective democratic governance on the Continent that have served as a seedbed for instabilities and major contributor of UCG. A process instead of an occurrence, UCG is not a happenstance but is at the core of a web of issues that have transpired to push over the edge and into regression.

The African continent has grappled with COVID-19, one of the worst pandemics in history, during which issues of democratic governance, and promotion of human rights temporarily took the back burner. Some political figures took advantage of the global focus on the pandemic to conduct a power grab - evidenced by countries undertaking constitutional reforms to extend the term limits of elected governments (in the case of Guinea) supporting the justification for the current setbacks. Socio-economic inequalities have been exasperated by skyrocketing living costs of citizens across the Continent. A more recent trend of global instability, war and security challenges, have also played a significant role in entrenching poverty further into the lives of Africans, thereby creating frustration and discontent evidenced by many popular protests.

The Instability caused by UCG spreads like wildfire creating an uninhabitable environment for citizens, not to mention creating a vacuum for power grab, corruption, foreign interference, and terrorism. Data suggests that approximately 4.6 million people in the Sahel, including approximately 1.3 million people in Burkina Faso have been displaced because of instability.

Breaking the Cycle of UCG depends on addressing democratic governance deficits. Deficit in democratic governance has compounded and hindered development, compromised sustainable peace and has been at the core of Africa's democratic governance challenges. Africa is in dire need of strong institutions and responsive governance systems that facilitate positive state-society relationships by providing independent and reliable channels between citizens and their governments. Political Parties, independent electoral bodies, independent judiciary, strong security sector, and strong civil society all play an important role in contributing to democratic governance processes that maintain the social contract and enhance trust between society and government. Building effective and strong democratic governance systems has the potential to address UCG among other ills by also addressing issues of inclusiveness and cohesion while bringing equitable share of dividends of democracy to the citizens.

The primary goal of the AU is its resolve to achieve the Aspirations set out in Agenda 2063. This grand plan of achieving "the Africa We Want" is hinged upon the AU's pillars of peace, unity, integration and prosperity. The AU believes that by focusing on these pillars, the Continent can achieve the goal of a democratic, peaceful, secure and prosperous Africa. Presently Agenda 2063's First Ten-Year Implementation Plan is coming to a close, paving a way for a successor plan. At this important juncture, the Union is at a crossroads in assessing the impact of the implementation of Agenda 2063 - specifically Aspiration 3 at the backdrop of Democratic governance reversals on the Continent.

Still, in furtherance of the blueprint of the Union, Normative and legal frameworks of the AU inclusive of the Constitutive Act unequivocally heed to the promotion of democratic governance on the Continent while strongly detesting UCG. Specifically, the Lomé Declaration expressed the heartbeat of MS of the Union in condemning military coups, foreign interventions, rebellions and armed dissent. The AU as a norm-setting organization has set the standard for Democracy and Governance. Dubbed as a progressive instrument, the African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance (ACDEG) is a legally binding instrument for MS that have acceded to the instruments. The Union further indoctrinated issues of democratic governance and peace through two important architectures that take these aspirations forward. The African Governance Architecture (AGA) and the African Peace and Security Architecture (APSA) both specifically specify modalities based on the commitment made by the AU MS.

Despite the existing normative frameworks, States are grappling with issues of UCG, military takeovers and insurgencies causing composite fragilities and insecurities in the Continent. The uptick in UCG in Mali, Guinea, Burkina Faso, Sudan and Chad has given a glimpse into the common denominator - democratic governance backsliding, weak institutions, corruption, diversity mismanagement, compounding socio-economic inequalities and discontent.

The AU and Regional Economic Communities (RECs) in most scenarios have acted quickly to condemn UCG, further moving to suspension of Membership and imposing sanctions. Effectiveness of the sanctions regime aside, condemnations of democratic governance backsliding by regional and international actors have brought about some changes as it was witnessed in Guinea and Mali. Ballots vs Bullets and strong democratic governance is the game in town and the African citizenry has also caught on to the tune. According to Afrobarometers's public opinion polls done in 34 African countries in the year 2019/2021, 82% of citizens reject one-man rule, 77% reject one-party rule and 75% reject military rule - an overwhelming number of citizens from the survey are also in favour of presidential term limits and prefer democracy than any other kind of government.

In recognition of these challenges, and the prevailing need to contribute, the African Governance Platform (AGP) has dedicated this year's theme of the 11th HLD as 'Breaking the Cycle of Unconstitutional Changes of Government through Strengthening Democratic Governance systems in Africa.' The discussions will address the democratic governance challenges as the root cause of UCG, highlight normative frameworks and how their effective implementation can counter UCG and also provide opportunities for in-depth discussions on the role of democratic elections, security sector and foreign interference. Discussions on UCG have been a priority to the AU this year. The Department of Political Affairs, Peace, and Security (DPAPS) has already organized a reflection forum in March 2022 in Accra, Ghana leading to the adoption of the Accra Declaration.

To further address this issue and add value to the ongoing conversation, the AGP aims to bring together thinkers and practitioners of African Governance not only to analyze causes and effects and proffer solutions but also to facilitate a roadmap of implementation. Additionally, the HLD will give effect to the declaration of Heads of State and government on UCG 28 May 2022, specifically the provision addressing the creation of a conducive environment for the effective participation of women and youth in political processes to address the impact of unconstitutional changes of government through the Pre-forums of the HLD. The HLD has inbuilt Pre-forums on Gender and Youth which are designed to provide a platform for citizens to voice their opinions and weigh in on the implementation of solutions.

As such, the11th HLD and its pre-events on Youth and Gender are scheduled to be held from 18 to 23 November 2022 in Benin, Cotonou. The President of the Republic of Benin, H.E. Patrice Talon is the host of the 11th of the HLD as well as the Champion of the outcomes of the deliberations. The HLD will be preceded by the Youth and Gender Pre forums scheduled to be held from 20 to 23 November 2022. Similarly, the discussions and outcomes of the Gender Pre forum and the Youth Consultation will be championed by H.E. Véronique Tognifodé, Minister of Social Affairs and Microfinance and H.E. Oswald Homeky, Minister of Youth and Sports. The outcomes of the Pre-forums will dovetail into the outcomes of the HLD.

The Dialogue will generally focus on the phenomenon of Unconstitutional Changes of Government. However, the below Sub-thematic areas will guide the discussions on addressing the root causes of UCG and address the key factors for the re-emergence. Discussions will give prominence to historical, legal and normative context, take a deep dive into specific thematic areas that were not given prominence in past discussions and provide a platform for stakeholders to share experiences, draw lessons and craft solutions and a pathway for implementation.

1. SETTING THE SCENE: ROOT CAUSES OF THE RE-EMERGENCE OF UCG IN AFRICA - Under this thematic section, the speakers will retrospect and have an honest and open discussion on the reasons for the re-emergence of UCG undermining political stability and democracy in Africa. By looking back, opportunities will be provided to draw lessons from the past and understand that UCG is not an occurrence but rather a series of events. The panelists will provide a guiding framework for robust discussions to examine the root causes for effective solutions.

2. ANALYSIS OF AU AND RECS NORMATIVE REGIME AGAINST UCG - This thematic area will provide an opportunity to explore the normative and legal framework of the AU and RECS specifically focusing on the AU Shared Values instruments on Democracy, Governance and Human Rights. The session will delve into controversial conversations of expectation vs reality on ratification and implementation and reporting of instruments by drawing a working linkage and the contributions AU Shared values make towards contributing to curbing UCG.

4. THE ROLE OF DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS IN PEACEFUL POLITICAL TRANSITIONS : Elections are the conventional mechanism for the peaceful and democratic transfer of political power. Military coups displace elections and the role of citizens in choosing their leaders and holding them to account. In most post-coup political settlements and transitions, elections are often considered the route to the restoration of democratic constitutional order by lending legitimacy to the new government. This session critically analyses the role of elections in creating conditions for UCG as well as the conduct of elections during political transitions which serve as building blocks for a democratic trajectory in countries emerging from military coups.

5. STRIKING THE BALANCE: SOCIOECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, DIVERSITY MANAGEMENT AND BUILDING RESILIENT INSTITUTIONS: This thematic area will discuss how violence and UCG often take place in environments with political and socio-economic instability. Therefore, it is crucial to strengthen socioeconomic progress and install a collaborative system between MS to help and support each other in times of need.

6.THE ROLE OF THE SECURITY SECTOR IN PEACEFUL TRANSITIONS AND COMBATING FOREIGN INTERVENTION: The role of this session is to facilitate the understanding of the importance of the defense and security sector as major stakeholders in the UCG discussion. The session aims to open the space for once a formerly restricted area into mainstream discussions to understand the role and critical issues of the security apparatus. More specifically, discussions on foreign interference and its role in the political destabilization of MS will be discussed to put forth the subject for open and frank conversations, solutions and way forward, and the importance of democratic governance for peace and security.

7. STRATEGIES FOR TRANSFORMATION: PERSPECTIVE OF IMPLEMENTING THE MALABO DECISION AND ACCRA DECLARATION: UCG, due to its increased occurrence in Africa, has been the topic of discussion. However, once UCG has occurred and discussions have taken place, it is important to prioritize the creation of a roadmap for implementation. This session discusses the role of the MS, AU, Organs and RECs, CSOs and other Stakeholders in taking practical steps in the implementation of the Malabo Decision and the Accra Declaration.

5.AFRICA TALKS: This intergenerational conversation is intended to showcase exceptional Africans to share their experiences and inspire change in their communities, contributing to the Africa We want. In this session, stories of young Africans that have made immense contributions to their communities through their leadership resilience and power will be featured.

6. INTERLUDE: Interludes between sessions will be provided through creative means by sharing inspiring and relevant performances of culture, music, art and videos that are meant to inspire participants.

Gender Pre-Forum- "Women's Political Participation as an Antidote for Unconstitutional Changes of Government"

Women make up to 50% of Africa's population and take a central role in strengthening democratic governance which is key to a peaceful and prosperous Africa. Often, women are only identified as victims and caregivers during violent conflicts, political unrest, military takeovers and coups in the continent. During violent conflicts and periods of insecurity, women are targeted and stripped of their rights of participating in decision-making and political processes, which directly affects the progress of the African Continent.

Moreover, recognizing and bolstering women's role in breaking this cycle of UCG is critical as it is the missing piece to the puzzle. Women are excellent leaders, mediators and have been found to be effective in ending and preventing violent conflict that have led to bloodshed. Although their contribution has often been less recognised, women played a significant role in liberation struggles and have fought wars against colonization and slavery. The women warriors of Dahomey Amazons from modern-day Republic of Benin are a stark illustration of women's contribution to our Continent in the fight against colonialism.

Women continue to contribute in many ways to the progress of the African continent, but this contribution is usually not recognised. Women have been in the front lines and have occupied spaces that have challenged military rule and have protested against coups. Women were and are still working in the background to challenge the status quo and lead efforts to make peace across communities and countries. However, the stories of women have always been overlooked, hijacked or not provided due attention they deserve. Women are problem solvers, and having them contribute to the conversation on how to resolve issues of UCG in the continent is paramount. Women are not leading coups but they are suffering from the consequences-they have a vested interest in creating an Africa where UCG are a thing of the past.

Research and practice have provided a clear linkage between the need for women's political participation and their positive impact on civil-military relations and reducing confrontations that lead to conflict. Strong empirical evidence has demonstrated that female leaders act less militaristically internationally and in interstate relations. Hence a strong linkage exists between promoting higher numbers of female representation in politics, in parliament and leadership positions and reducing the risk of coups.

Creating a platform for conversations that attend to the realities of African women and register their contributions as well as recommendations for reversing UCG is critical. Due to the re-emergence of UCG in the African Continent, interlinked with security issues like the proliferation of terrorism, the enhancement of women's participation in politics and decision-making processes is not only an assurance of Africa's commitment to progress but can be a mechanism of de-escalating possible security challenges and reversing UCG in the Continent.

It is in light of this rationale that the African Union Organs and Institutions that form the African Governance Platform through the AGA -APSA Secretariat are organizing the annual Gender Pre-Forum to the 11th High-Level Dialogue under the theme of "Women's Political Participation as Antidote for Unconstitutional Changes of Government" from 20 to 21 November 2022 in Cotonou, Benin.

Continental Youth Consultation - "The Roles and Perspectives of Young People in Reversing Unconstitutional Changes of Government"

Africa's population is the youngest in the world. As such, any progress that is sought to be made without considering the perspectives of young people would seem like taking one step forward and two steps back. The African Union has put the youth as its main stakeholder in its efforts to promote democracy and good governance within Member States. The core instruments of the African Union, namely its Constitutive Act, the Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance (ACDEG), OAU/AU Declaration on Principles Governing Democratic Elections, the (Algiers and Lomé) Declarations on Unconstitutional Changes of Government, and the African Union Convention on Preventing and Combating Corruption have all made foundational principles against UCG. The African Union in recognition of the same has called for concerted efforts in addressing deficits and structural causes of UCG.

Norms and standards have been set for improved democratic principles and practices. These are also manifested by the active participation of and mainstreaming of youth and women not only in dialogues or discussions but in practical steps to improve and build governance systems and institutions, strengthen civil society, civil-military relations and address socio-economic exclusion, and management of diversity.

More particularly, a call has been made to Member States to engage youth, continue to design mechanisms and create a conducive environment for the effective participation of youth in peace and development processes at national, regional and continental levels. This will promote the important roles and contributions of women and youth in the promotion of democracy, good governance, sustainable peace, security and development in the Continent. Additionally, Member States have been encouraged to consider creating continental youth programs to enable the youth to engage and participate in democratic governance matters.

Taking the importance of engaging youth and the role young people play not only as beneficiaries but as partners and leaders, the African Union organs and institutions that form the African Governance Architecture (AGA) Secretariat on behalf of the Platform (AGP) have organized under the auspices of the African Governance Architecture a Youth Engagement Strategy (YES) youth programming that aims to increase the capacities of youth and engage them in a constructive dialogue. The Capacity building is hinged upon an African Union Continental Manual on Youth Engagement in Political and Democratic Processes in the Continent. This free manual can be downloaded on the AU website, and youth, Member States and organizations have access to it to provide targeted capacity for young people to engage meaningfully in democratic governance issues.

As part of an effort to give opportunities for young people to deliberate on issues of democratic governance, the African Governance Platform has institutionalized Continental/regional Youth Consultations before the High Level Dialogue. This year, youth will come together to deliberate about "The Roles and Perspectives of Young People in reversing Unconstitutional Changes of Government." The Consultation was dedicated to this topic because of the particular value young people can bring into the conversations, to gain perspectives on issues affecting their lives and solicit ideas and solutions as well as highlight their role in reversing UCG on the Continent.

The Continental Youth Consultation is scheduled to take place from 18 - 19 November 2022 in Cotonou, Benin.

The overall goal of the 11^thHigh-Level Dialogue is to assess, identify and explore normative, structural enablers to achieve democratic governance, peace, and security in Africa. Specifically, the Dialogue will provide a platform to share evidence-based knowledge and analysis as well as exchange comparable lessons and experiences in democratic governance, peace, and security while also developing policy recommendations to address the upsurge of UCG.

The specific objectives of the High-Level Dialogue are to:

1. Examine the root causes of Unconstitutional Changes of Government as key contributors to the recent upsurge, understanding UCG as a culmination of democratic governance and socio-economic lapses and not as unrelated occurrences;
2. Increase the understanding of normative and institutional frameworks that exist at all levels related to the protection of Democracy, Elections, Constitutionalism, Conflict-Prevention, Peace, and Security;
3. Create a collaborative space for intergenerational reflections on cross-cutting issues like socio-economic development and equitable distribution of wealth, women and youth engagement, and institutional capacity building;
4. Provide a platform for African citizens to share their experiences and lessons learned as well as headline conversations as major stakeholders in the achievement of practical steps to implement decisions and ultimately prevent UCG in Africa; and
5. Contribute to the discourse of discussions that have already been made on UCG, to curate and proffer a deep dive into the roadmap for the implementation of solutions for UCG on the continent.

1. Set the scene on the current state of Governance, peace, and security as a contributor to the process culminating to UCG to clear the pathway for identifying specific challenges and tracking progress;
2. Ideate on inclusive solutions for improved ratification, implementation and monitoring of AU Shared Values instruments identified;
3. Offer space for outlining practical steps and roadmap for the implementation declarations and recommendations against UCG;
4. Renewed commitment for addressing democratic governance and socio-economic issues as key factors for removing UCG from our African Continent and Dictionary;

Established in 2012, the AGA was created as a framework for dialogue between various stakeholders mandated to promote and strengthen democratic governance in Africa as articulated in the various AU Shared Values instruments. Its establishment was premised on the dire need to enhance the impact of various AU and RECs interventions in addressing governance deficits on the continent. The Secretariat is hosted by DPAPS as the Bureau of the AGP.

The AGP is the institutional and interactive mechanism of the AGA. The Platform is composed of nineteen (19) AU Organs, Institutions and Regional Economic Communities (RECs). In this regard, the Platform has a responsibility of enhancing the capacity of its stakeholders to support the Member States in promoting democratic governance. The Platform comprises eleven (11) AU Organs and institutions with a Human Rights, Democracy and Governance mandate as well as the eight (8) RECs. Critical stakeholders that have been taking part through observing are the Chairperson of the PRC Subcommittee on Human Rights democracy and Governance (HRDG) Regional Mechanisms, Special envoys for youth and women and AU Offices outside of Addis.

On a rotational basis of two years, the Chairperson and Vice Chairperson of the AGP take on the leadership of the AGP at the Technical and Political level with the AU Commission through the DPAPS being the permanent Rapporteur. The Current Chairperson and Vice Chairperson of the AGP are the African Commission on Human and People's Rights (ACHPR) also known as 'The Banjul Commission' and Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD).

The AGA Secretariat was set up to serve the AGP and facilitate coordination and synergies among the platform members. The ongoing AU Reform implementation processes recognize the importance of synergies between the AGA and the APSA and have brought the operational arms of the architectures together by creating the AGA-APSA Secretariat. The implementation of the AU Reforms is still ongoing.

1. Declaration on Terrorism and Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa https://au.int/en/node/41855
2. African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance https://au.int/en/treaties/african-charter-democracy-elections-and-governance
3. Agenda 2063 Aspirations for the Africa We Want https://au.int/en/agenda2063/aspirations
4. Manuals on Youth Participation in Political and Electoral Processes in Africa https://au.int/node/41284
5. African Youth Charter
   https://au.int/treaties/african-youth-charter
6. Governance treaties
   https://au.int/treaties/1163