08/23/2024 | Press release | Distributed by Public on 08/23/2024 12:54
Key takeaways:
Medical cost-sharing programs are also sometimes referred to as healthcare sharing plans, healthcare sharing ministries, or simply health sharing plans. In these communal models, group members pool their money to collectively cover everyone's approved medical costs.
Healthcare sharing programs are not health insurance. They work differently and offer an alternative way to pay for medical bills.
Members of healthcare sharing plans usually pay less per month to belong to these programs than they would to have health insurance coverage. But medical cost-sharing programs have financial risks and members can - and have - ended up with unpaid bills and medical debt.
With medical cost-sharing programs - also called healthcare sharing plans, healthcare sharing ministries, or simply health sharing plans - members make monthly payments into a pool of money that's used to cover everyone's approved healthcare costs.
Medical cost-sharing programs generally have lower upfront costs than health insurance plans, which is a major incentive for people who join these programs. An estimated 1.7 million people in the U.S. are members of healthcare sharing plans, according to KFF Health News.
Medical cost-sharing monthly payments are not premiums and the programs work differently from health insurance plans. They're typically run by nonprofit organizations and members often share religious or ethical beliefs. Sometimes, applicants are even required to sign a statement of faith.
Looking for free or low-cost health insurance?Explore options including Medicaid, Medicare special needs plans, and Affordable Care Act plans.
Medical bills and your credit score: Find out how unpaid medical bills can hurt your credit score and what you can do about it.
Don't wait till your divorce is finalized before figuring out health insurance.If you're losing coverage because of a divorce, it's a good idea to look at your options sooner than later.
Members of medical cost-sharing programs pay a set monthly amount into a group fund as part of their annual household portion. When a member receives a large medical bill, they can put in a share request to use the collective funds to cover some or all of their charges.
Many medical cost-sharing programs urge members to seek low-cost healthcare or charity care before requesting a payout. Some encourage members to see healthcare professionals that offer discounted rates. Others limit payouts to what they consider to be a "fair and reasonable amount," which is typically less than the cost of services. When this happens, members are responsible for paying any remaining expenses on their own.
It's important to note that medical cost-sharing programs are not legally obligated to cover the healthcare costs of members.
It's important to weigh the pros and cons of medical cost-sharing programs before joining one.
Here are some of the benefits:
Reduced monthly payments: Medical cost-sharing programs typically have lower monthly costs than health insurance plans. For example, a medical cost-sharing member might pay around $133 a month. The average price for a bronze-level plan - the lowest-cost tier of insurance available on the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace - in 2024 was $364 a month. Though, in some cases, premium tax credits, also known as premium subsidies, may be able to reduce ACA plan monthly payments significantly.
Coverage flexibility: Some medical cost-sharing programs cover items - such as overseas medical treatments, adoption expenses, or funeral costs - that health insurance plans don't.
Sense of community: Since members are typically like-minded or have religious cohesion, individuals may feel good about contributing to the well-being of others. For some, this social aspect is as attractive as the potential financial benefits.
No open enrollment period: Members can join medical cost-sharing programs at any time, provided they meet the requirements. This means no waiting for open enrollment periods.
Here are some of the disadvantages:
Limited protections: In general, medical cost-sharing programs don't offer the same protections as health insurance plans. They're also not covered under the No Surprises Act, which helps people avoid surprise medical bills.
No coverage guarantee: Medical cost-sharing programs aren't legally required to pay healthcare costs for members. A member could contribute funds for months or even years without receiving a payout. A 2024 Seattle TV station probe found that nearly 200 complaints have been filed against healthcare sharing ministries in the last 3 years for not paying the bills of members. A ProPublica investigation of Liberty HealthShare published in 2023 revealed that the organization's members faced millions of dollars in medical debt after not receiving payouts.
Unregulated products: State insurance regulators don't supervise or regulate medical cost-sharing programs or how much members pay for them.
Limited eligibility: Members may need to agree to strict spiritual or lifestyle guidelines to qualify for a medical cost-sharing program. If your submitted bill is deemed to fall outside of those guidelines, your request for payment could be rejected.
Confusing terms and limitations: Not all medical cost-sharing programs are transparent about their coverage rules and restrictions, though some limit how many medical visits they'll cover annually and/or have a waiting period before coverage begins. Many programs also have an annual unshared amount that, like an insurance deductible, has to be paid before members are eligible for payouts. Unlike health insurance plans that fall under ACA regulations, medical cost-sharing programs are not required to cover essential health benefits. But some use misleading marketing that may cause consumers to think they work like health insurance plans.
If you're considering signing up for a medical cost-sharing program, it's important to understand what you'd be buying into and how the program is different from health insurance. Here are some questions to ask:
What are the program's guidelines, including lifestyle or religious rules?
What services will it cover and are there any guarantees for coverage?
What are the program's limitations?
Does the organization have a reputation of helping its members with their medical bills?
What are my out-of-pocket costs going to look like?
Will I end up paying more or less than if I joined a health insurance plan?
Will I be required to see certain healthcare professionals?
Does the program partner with any healthcare professionals and facilities where I can access care at discounted rates?
Can I appeal sharing decisions and, if so, how?
What protections or guarantees does the program offer its members?
What happens if the program doesn't pay my bills?
It's important for you to thoroughly read and understand an agreement with a medical cost-sharing program before signing it. You should also be aware that members have filed lawsuits against medical cost-sharing programs in recent years for unpaid medical bills.
The Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries, a trade organization that represents seven large health sharing programs, reported that its member organizations covered $1.1 billion in medical expenses in 2023. The alliance didn't report how many bills (or how much in total) went unpaid for members, however.
Examples of healthcare services that medical cost-sharing plans typically don't cover include:
Alcohol use disorder treatments
Reproductive healthcare services, including contraception, fertility treatments, and abortions
Medical cost-sharing programs run by Christian organizations generally don't cover healthcare services that clash with the group's outlined lifestyle and religious beliefs. Some programs also have a long waiting period during which members receive limited or zero assistance with medical bills.
Yes, it's possible to lose your membership with a medical cost-sharing plan. Here are some situations in which your membership might be be revoked:
You've enrolled in a religious cost-sharing program, but your lifestyle or beliefs are no longer aligned.
You've reached a certain age - such as 65 - and no longer qualify for membership.
You can't keep up with the monthly payments.
You use illegal drugs or break other plan rules.
Review a program's guidelines carefully before signing up to make sure they agree with your lifestyle and needs.
According to the Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms, here are the largest healthcare sharing plans operating in the U.S.:
Altrua HealthShare
Christian Healthcare Ministries
Medi-Share
Samaritan Ministries
Sedera Medical Cost Sharing Community
Solidarity HealthShare
Liberty HealthShare
Medical cost-sharing programs are sometimes called healthcare sharing plans, healthcare sharing ministries, or health sharing plans. These arrangements are not health insurance and aren't regulated like health insurance plans. While medical cost-sharing programs may offer lower monthly costs than health insurance plans, membership doesn't guarantee that your healthcare costs will be covered. Medical cost-sharing programs are also not subject to the same consumer protections as health insurance.
Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. (n.d.). By the numbers.
Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. (n.d.). Frequently asked questions.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2023). The No Surprises Act protects people who use private insurance or don't have or use insurance.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2024). Minimum essential coverage.
Christian Care Ministry. (n.d.). Medi-Share complete guidelines.
Christian Healthcare Ministries. (n.d.). Interacting with providers.
Colorado Department of Regulatory Agencies. (2023). First annual report on health care sharing plans and arrangements from Colorado Division of Insurance.
Gabrielson, R., et al. (2023). A Christian health nonprofit saddled thousands with debt as it built a family empire including a pot farm, a bank and an airline. ProPublica.
Hawryluk, M. (2023). At least 1.7m Americans use health sharing arrangements, despite lack of protections. KFF Health News.
Healthinsurance.org. (n.d.). Health care sharing ministry: What is a health care sharing ministry?
Herman, B. (2022). Florida hospital system sues religious sharing ministry over unpaid medical claims. STAT.
KFF. (2024). Average marketplace premiums by metal tier, 2018-2024.
King5.com. (2024). 'Don't fall for it': Healthcare sharing ministries look like insurance, but they're not.
Long, W. (2024). Best healthshare plans comparison guide 2024. HSA for America.
Medi-Share. (2021). Program guidelines.
National Association of Insurance Commissioners. (2022). Not all products are health insurance: Health care sharing ministries, discount plans and risk-sharing plans.
National Association of Insurance Commissioners. (2023). What you should know about health care sharing ministries, discount plans, and risk-sharing plans.
Samaritan Ministries. (n.d.). Samaritan Ministries and medical professionals.
Sedera. (n.d.). Frequently asked questions.
Stovicek, N., et al. (2023). Health care sharing ministry data point to problems for consumers, regulators. CHIRblog.
Ulrich, T. (2022). 'I pray you pay my bill': Consumers say religious medical sharing program didn't cover medical bills. WFTV.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2023). Private health coverage: Information on Farm Bureau health plans, health care sharing ministries, and fixed indemnity plans.
Volk, J., et al. (2018). Health care sharing ministries: What are the risks to consumers and insurance markets? The Commonwealth Fund.
Warren, K. (2023). What are health care sharing ministries (HCSMs)? Investopedia.
By signing up, I agree to GoodRx's Terms and Privacy Policy, and to receive marketing messages from GoodRx.