Norway's Renewable Energy Paradox Explained

This article draws from a panel debate at Arendalsuka, featuring Camilla Nilsson (Kyoto Group), Gunnar Birkeland (Goliath Wind), John Markus Lervik (Cognite), and Siren Sundby (Capgemini). They discuss why Norway, despite its energy wealth and global leadership in clean tech, lags in its domestic renewable energy transition.

Norway's Energy Paradox: Rich in Resources, Slow in Transition

Norway, renowned for its abundant natural resources and energy wealth, stands at a curious crossroads: While the country has amassed significant wealth from its oil and gas reserves, its domestic transition to renewable energy sources is moving at a slower pace compared to its international counterparts. This paradox raises an intriguing question: why is a nation, so rich in energy resources, not leading the charge in domestic renewable energy deployment?

Or as Kyoto Group CEO Camilla Nilsson says, framing the question:

- Norway's renewable energy boom is happening out there ... We talk to 50 industrial clients throughout Europe, producing everything from medicine to the paper in the Amazon boxes you receive. 50 clients. Only two of our clients are in Norway. This gives an idea of the activity level in Europe and in Norway - and that's what we must talk about.

Nilsson points out that the crux of this paradox lies in historical reliance on fossil fuels, existing infrastructure, and regulatory hurdles. Despite the country's potential for offshore wind, for example, projects have lagged.

- Norwegian innovative companies are working abroad with little activity at home, Camilla Nilsson says.

- We are green technology leaders, but we can't get electricity. The challenge is not just about transitioning energy sources but also about reimagining the energy landscape to accommodate new technologies and sustainable practices.

The Promise of Offshore Wind: A Solution Yet to Be Fully Realized

Offshore wind presents a significant opportunity for Norway to harness its natural advantages and propel its renewable energy ambitions. The country's extensive coastline and favourable wind conditions make it an ideal candidate for developing large-scale offshore wind farms. Yet, despite these advantages, the deployment and scaling of offshore wind projects have been slower than anticipated.

- What we need is floating offshore wind developments at scale, chairman of the Goliath Wind project Gunnar Birkeland says.

The potential of offshore wind lies not only in its capacity to generate clean energy but also in its ability to catalyze economic growth and innovation. However, realizing this promise requires overcoming financial, regulatory, and technological barriers.

Birkeland adds:

- What we are missing is an agreement across political parties that we need offshore wind.

The path to widespread adoption is paved with the need for supportive policies, investment in grid infrastructure, and collaboration between government and industry stakeholders.

Gunnar Birkeland stresses that right now, Norway has strong competence in the field. However, he says, things are on the move elsewhere too.

- We are ahead, but other countries will catch up if we don't step up our investments.

From left: Gunnar Birkeland, Camillla Nilsson and Siren Sundby

Understanding the Challenges: Energy Deficit and Grid Limitations

One of the primary challenges Norway faces in its renewable energy transition is an impending energy deficit.

- We are already starting to feel this, Camilla Nilsson says.

Despite its rich energy resources, the country is experiencing a strain on its electricity supply, which is projected to become more acute in the coming years. This constraint poses a significant hurdle for industries looking to decarbonize and adopt new technologies.

Moreover, the limitations of the existing grid infrastructure hinder the efficient integration of renewable energy sources. Upgrading and expanding the grid to accommodate decentralized power generation is essential for supporting the energy transition. This requires strategic investment and planning to ensure that the grid can handle increased loads and facilitate the distribution of renewable energy across the country.

Norwegian Innovation Abroad: Success Stories and Missed Opportunities

Norwegian companies have made significant strides in the global renewable energy market, showcasing innovation and leadership in various sectors. Companies like Kyoto Group are leading examples of how Norwegian expertise is making a mark internationally, particularly in areas like thermal energy storage and industrial decarbonization.

Kyoto Group has attracted major European investors like Iberdrola and Spirax Group. However, as Camilla Nilsson says:

- Less than 5% of our capital is Norwegian.

This highlights a missed opportunity for Norway. While Norwegian innovations are being adopted and scaled globally, the same level of activity is not mirrored within the country. The lack of domestic incentives and support for renewable energy projects means that Norwegian companies often find more favourable conditions and opportunities outside their home market.

Gunnar Birkeland touches on this as well, noting:

- We need to create home markets, to build large-scale developments of tens of billions of NOKs, with everything being new technology.

This diaspora of innovation underscores the need for Norway to create a more conducive environment for renewable energy development within its borders.

Comparative Insights: How Other Countries Are Leading the Way

Globally, several countries are setting benchmarks in renewable energy adoption and scaling. Nations like the United States and regions like the Middle East have implemented robust policies and incentives to accelerate the transition to clean energy.

- The U.S. has an ability to make decisions and move at a much faster pace than we are currently doing, says John Markus Lervik of Cognite.

He highlights the Inflation Reduction Act as a clear example of how strong financial incentives can drive significant investment in clean technology.

- It's a tiny amount of money in the grand scheme of things, and that 1% can really kill two birds with one stone.

Birkeland from the Goliath Wind project agrees. He says countries in the Middle East are mandating the use of AI and digital technologies in government projects to drive transformation.

- You don't see that in many other countries - developers having a common data plattform and sharing data.

He says that Norway can learn from these early adopters by crafting policies that incentivize innovation, attract investment, and ensure energy security for the future.

The Role of Policy and Regulation in Accelerating Change

Policy and regulation play a pivotal role in shaping the renewable energy landscape. In Norway, the need for clear, consistent, and supportive regulatory frameworks is critical to overcoming the barriers to renewable energy adoption. Policies that provide financial incentives, streamline permitting processes, and encourage collaboration between public and private sectors can significantly accelerate the transition.

Or as Siren Sundby of Capgemini puts it:

- Regulations force money in a certain direction.

By establishing mechanisms that balance supply and demand, Norway can ensure that renewable energy projects are economically viable and attractive to investors. This strategic alignment between policy and market dynamics is crucial for driving the country's renewable energy ambitions forward.

- Politicians in Norway should walk the talk and funnel som of the country's oil and gas money into new, green businesses.

The Digital Divide: Leveraging Technology for Energy Efficiency

In the era of digital transformation, technology is a key enabler of energy efficiency and sustainability. Digital solutions, such as AI and data analytics, offer immense potential to optimize energy use, enhance grid management, and reduce carbon footprints.

However, as Cognite's John Markus Lervik points out:

- In Norway, we are relatively digitally immature. The speed of the world is increasing rapidly, and we are not moving quickly enough.

This digital "lagging behind" isposing a challenge to fully leveraging new technologies for the energy transition.

To bridge this digital divide, investments in digital infrastructure and skills development are essential. By fostering a culture of innovation and embracing digital tools, Norway can enhance its energy efficiency and competitiveness on a global scale. Collaboration between technology providers, industry players, and government agencies will be crucial in realizing the full potential of digital technologies in the renewable energy sector.

From left: Siren Sundby, Camilla Nilsson and John Markus Lervik

Call to Action: What Norway Can Do to Lead in Renewable Energy

The path to leadership in renewable energy requires bold actions and a collective commitment to change. Norway stands at a pivotal moment where it can redefine its energy future and emerge as a global leader in the transition to sustainable energy. To achieve this, a multi-faceted approach is needed-one that includes policy reform, investment in infrastructure, and fostering a culture of innovation.

- We need to trigger politicians to really support and understand the business case, Siren Sundby from Capgemini says.

Norwegian policymakers need to prioritize renewable energy as a national imperative, setting clear targets and providing the necessary support to achieve them. Industry leaders should collaborate to share knowledge, develop new technologies, and create synergies that drive progress. By leveraging its natural resources, technological expertise, and innovative spirit, Norway can harness the opportunity to lead the world in renewable energy and secure a sustainable future for generations to come.

Or as Kyoto Group's Camilla Nilsson has put it elsewhere:

- We need politicians who dare to say that this will hurt temporarily. The world needs that. Before we can all feel better, we have to go through some pain. Maybe the pain will pass quickly, or maybe it will take some time, but we have to go through it. Together. If politicians inflict pain, new energy technology companies will come up with a solution.

See the whole recording from Kyoto Group's event at Arendalsuka 2024.

Public link

Please use the above public link if you want to share this noodl on another website.